Quantcast

Real ‘Woman of the Year’

1/1/2016, 10:13 a.m.
Jannie Ligons is an Oklahoma City grandmother who left a friend’s house to drive home. She collided with Daniel Holtzclaw, ...
Julianne Malveaux

Julianne Malveaux

Jannie Ligons is an Oklahoma City grandmother who left a friend’s house to drive home. She collided with Daniel Holtzclaw, the rogue police officer who seemed to think it was part of his duty to sexually abuse black women. He raped them because he could. They did not accuse him because they feared they could not. Some of the women had criminal records — they had been involved with drugs or had other skirmishes with the law. They felt both vulnerable and violated, and they thought nobody would believe them.

At least 13 women were violated. They were identified only because one courageous woman, Jannie Ligons, took her complaint to the police. She had no criminal record and nothing to hide. She simply had the harrowing experience of encountering a white (really half Japanese, but that’s another story) man with a badge, feelings of superior racial identity and a penis. According to many of the accounts of women who encountered Mr. Holtzclaw, he referred to his whiteness as he violated them. Many of the women had other matters with the law, and he intimidated them into silence.

In our nation’s sordid history, when black women spoke, they found themselves denigrated or ignored. In 1944, Recy Taylor, a 24-year-old mother, was abducted as she walked from church with her friends in Henry County, Ala. A car full of white men threatened her with a shotgun, then took her into an abandoned field and repeatedly raped her. The men who raped Ms. Taylor said she welcomed the sex and they paid her. They could have been arrested, but a complicit sheriff ignored the law. When an all-white jury heard the case, they failed to indict the six men. In 2011, Alabama offered Ms. Taylor an apology for failing to properly manage the case. Justice delayed is justice denied.

There are too many black women raped by white men whose experiences are swallowed in the vacuum of history. There are some experiences that have been captured, though. Consider Betty Jean Owens, a Florida A&M University student, who was talking with three friends when a group of white men, armed with shotguns and switchblades abducted her in 1959. They admitted, as they were arrested, that they were looking for a black woman to rape, and made jokes about it. The horrible criminals might have escaped prosecution and gotten away with their crime had not a young white police intern organized a search party to find Ms. Owens. Had there been no protests or national attention, the rapists may have been acquitted. They were convicted, but Ms. Owens was further demeaned through a trial that questioned her virtue and asserted that she didn’t fight hard enough, even with a shotgun at her head. Her dress, they said, wasn’t torn enough to indicate a rape. Unexpectedly, the all-white jury found the rapists guilty. They were given life sentences. At least one of them was paroled to rape and kill again — and he did.